Can You be Disobedient?

Henry David Thoreau was disgusted by slavery and the Mexican American War. In prosets, he offered the idea of civil disobedience. This is the act of being unruly in order to protest the government and its actions. I really took to this idea of being able to protest and be a non-conformist if you disagree with the government. 

In class on Thursday 12/12/08, we had a speaker come in and talk about her acts of cimil disobedience. A lady who had been arrested nearly 60 times in her life, all to protest what she thought was the government's abuse of power. The most dramatic of her tales was when she was in Iraq, against strict protocol, helping families that were affected by the US invasion. She conveyed to us with her voice and expression the same emotion that she must have felt while in Iraq. I was left speechless. She believes non-violent protest and civil disobedience are the most potent way of getting your voice heard.

My main question now is, can people perform acts of civil disobedience and still be active members of society? The speaker we had, after all, doesn't pay taxes and owns not a single automobile. So how can a New Trier student or faculty aspire to live in open protest to the government if we want, without being seen as strange or outcasts? 

The answer is... he or she probable cannot. In Thoreau's day, the government was still young and ripe for protest. Now, we are so used to the governments practices that any protest besides an anti-war march seems too edgy. I wish there was a way to open forum our protests to the government without having to break the law. 

Our speaker laid it out for us. In order to live her lifestyle, she made a decision to change her normal way of life. For a high school student wanting to go on to college and beyond, I just can't see myself being able to protest in such ways. 

What We Really Need

Henry David Thoreau spent two years in solitude while according observations for his book, Walden. In these two years he determined that man has only 4 requirements he must maintain for himself in order to survive: fuel, food, shelter, and clothing. A perfectly functioning human being can exist so long as he quenches these 4 thirsts. 

With the holiday season in full swing, it is a good time to consider what the brilliant Thoreau had to offer us. When we sit down to make our holiday lists, what should we ask for so that we don't bury ourselves with "not indispensable" items. When I asked myself that question, I remembered hearing about a sponsorship charities, like the Christian Children's Fund , in which a small portion of our money goes to ensure that children in third world countries do not go without the 4 basic needs. 

It is very hard to live like a transcendentalist today, with more  and more people worry about looks and luxuries. How can we strive to be individualists, when advertisements insult us with their low brow humor-- trying to connect with the common man?Advertisements are just plain bad. 

Anyway, I hope we live conscious of Thoreau's efforts to show us that we can live happy without the luxuries.